Calm after the storm although transition begins to lag | 2023 year in review

This year saw a return to relative calmness after the energy shocks of last year, while governments are playing an increasing role as the rate of new renewable generation lags.

Spot pricing was subdued compared to last year, with no significant unexpected outages that caused sustained price spikes. Higher levels of renewable generation, including burgeoning levels of rooftop solar, suppressed pricing during the daytime hours. Federal Government interventions, namely applying a coal price cap and gas price ‘anchor’, also applied some downward pressure on input costs that translated into lower prices.

Figure 2: Average quarterly prices (2019-23)

Source: AEMO data, Cornwall Insight Australia analysis

Government interventions were another big story of the year, as both state and federal governments intervened frequently to support the renewable energy transition. The pièce de resistance of interventions was the Federal Government’s dramatic boosting of the Capacity Investment Scheme from an initial 6GW to now 32GW (23GW renewable generation plus 9GW firming) of revenue underwriting. States also intervened, with Victoria setting up the State Electricity Commission to potentially directly co-invest in renewable energy projects, while New South Wales may set up a similar vehicle. New South Wales also continues to roll out regular tenders for REZ Access rights and generation/storage support, while the Queensland Government is supporting the CopperString 1100km transmission line in the northern part of the state, a non-ISP project.

Concern over a stalled energy transition is driving these interventions. Australia is currently behind the pace of meeting the Federal Government’s renewable energy target of 82% by 2030. The reasons for stalled investment include lack of transmission capacity, slow project approvals and connections, financing, labour skills shortages and lack of social licence. The Federal Government is aiming to tackle most of these roadblocks, such as underwriting transmission investment through the Rewiring the Nation scheme, providing additional funding for AEMO to speed up connections for this upcoming summer, and boosting the Capacity Investment Scheme. However, social licence remains a prickly area as regional communities increasingly disapprove of overhead transmission lines and large renewable generation.

The year also saw the retirement of the Liddell baseload coal-fired station in NSW. The station was retired in April, although it has been operating at reduced capacity in the preceding quarters. There was no significant disruption from Liddell’s retirement due to a largely benign market (no major outages or heat waves – yet). The next big retirement is the 2,922MW Eraring station in NSW, which is due to retire in 2025. The New South Wales Government made noises this year about extending Eraring, which may make achieving renewable energy targets more difficult unless there is enough renewable/firm replacement supply.

Internationally, COP28 adopted a resolution for the transition away from fossil fuels. The resolution is non-binding and was watered down from the original language of ceasing fossil fuel use entirely. However, the resolution could be most powerful in sending a signal to governments, investors, and corporations that fossil fuel use should eventually wane. This could be powerful in a similar fashion to the Paris Agreement of 2015, which helped drive decision-makers towards net-zero goals even though the accord did not mention net zero itself.

The year was capped off with AEMO’s draft 2024 ISP release. This draft has to comply with hitting the Federal Government’s renewable energy target. As the NEM is not currently on track to hit this target, the scenarios presented in this ISP are a mix of aspiration and forecast. The draft ISP is notable for including offshore wind (due to state targets) and calling for more flexible gas as a source of firming.

El Nino weather disruptions hang like a cloud over this coming summer. The prospect of a string of hot days over capital cities may push the NEM to the edge if there are also unexpected generation or interconnector outages. AEMO and governments will likely intervene in extreme scenarios through RERT (demand response) and potential AEMO directions.  

The above focus article is derived from our monthly Energy Executive Summary. Please contact us for further information on this service.

Related thinking

Announcement

Offshore wind now appears in latest ISP

The ISP also forecasts that greater flexible gas generation is needed From Cornwall Insight Australia's Energy Market Alerts service Offshore wind officially appears in the draft 2024 ISP due to state-based offshore wind targets. Figure 1 below from our latest Energy Market Alert, shows the variance in forecast generation between...

Announcement

Very Fast FCAS markets in the NEM

Cornwall Insight Australia released the latest Frequency Control Ancillary Service (FCAS) price curves for Q4 2023. The two new Very Fast FCAS markets have begun, and with this report, Cornwall Insight Australia explores how they’re evolving and what the future outlook of these markets holds. Detailing a full 20-year interval...

Commercial and market outlook

Latest Benchmark power curve insight

Cornwall Insight Australia has released our latest NEM Benchmark power curve (NEM BPC) for Q4 2023 to our subscribers. Our latest edition includes Marinus Link, ESSO constraints and other updates. We have released a free excerpt, which you can access below.The Federal Government has announced a partnership with the Marinus Link...

Net zero corporates and ESG

Race to net zero: Rebuilding investor confidence in the UK

In our recent insight paper “Race to net zero: Rebuilding investor confidence in the UK”, published on 30 November, we discuss how increased macroeconomic pressures and rising international competition for capital have impacted the UK’s ability to secure investment in renewables and maintain momentum towards net zero. We also investigate...

Announcement

New South Wales REZ outlook

From Cornwall Insight Australia's Energy Market Perspective Our quarterly Energy Market Perspective contains an analysis of indicative capacity at REZ zones throughout the NEM.  The following assessment for NSW is from our latest edition. Request Energy Market Perspective call back The strategic development of Renewable Energy Zones (REZs) in New...

Announcement

Capacity Investment Scheme boosted from 6GW to 32GW

From Cornwall Insight Australia's Energy Market Alerts service Last Friday, the Commonwealth announced a major boost to the Capacity Investment Scheme, with the scheme now expected to deliver 32GW (combination of 9GW firming capacity and 23GW renewable generation) – up from 6GW. Cornwall Insight Australia has released an Energy Market...

Announcement

What are Australia’s emissions reduction targets?

From Cornwall Insight Australia's Energy Market Alerts service Energy laws have now been amended to incorporate an emissions reduction objective alongside the other objectives. The list of targets that the market bodies will need to consider is listed in a separately published Targets Statement. The targets currently listed cover both...

Announcement

Energy prices tumble in October

From Cornwall Insight Australia’s NEM Market Analysis report With over 700 GWh of rooftop PV added to the NEM since October last year, records were again set in NEM minimum demands along with a high instantaneous renewable penetration within the grid of 71.4%. Once again, the month’s main story was...