ESB and Cornwall Insight Australia provide final advice to energy ministers

Last week, the Energy Security Board (ESB) released its recommendations for the redesign of the National Electricity Market (NEM). Cornwall Insight Australia (CIA) was engaged by the ESB to assess the potential benefit of the proposed essential system service reform package for system strength provision.

The report detailed that these benefits arise both from more cost-effective investment and sharing of system strength assets, and more efficient use of the existing generation fleet that supplies this service at operational timeframe.

It also stated these reforms deliver a robust power system that can endure the transition to a low emissions system and harness the benefits that renewable energy has to offer.

George Wong, Senior Modelling Consultant at Cornwall Insight Australia, said:

“To date, system strength shortfall has caused ongoing connections delay and operational curtailment for renewable assets across the NEM. To enhance the provision of system strength in the NEM, the ESB has proposed to introduce reforms targeting both the investment and operational timeframes, including the Unit Commitment for Security (UCS), the System Security Mechanism (SSM) and TNSP system strength procurement mechanism reforms.

“Our current modelling found that the potential net benefit of the proposed reform package is approximately up to $1.2Bn in Net Present Value over the modelling period, which covers the period between financial years 2022/23 to 2039/40.”

The figure below (Figure 21 of the ESB Report Part B) shows the cost difference breakdown by year, over the modelling period for the upper bound scenario. Comparing capital expenditure (CAPEX) and operating cost (OPEX), we can see the resulted net benefits for the reform package.

Figure 1: Overall cost difference by year and expenditure type for upper bound scenario

More information on the report and recommendations can be found here:

Related thinking


Latest FCAS price curves Q1 2024

Cornwall Insight Australia released the latest Frequency Control Ancillary Service (FCAS) price curves for Q1 2024. The new Very Fast FCAS markets have 3 more months in the books, and as they settle into a reasonably stable quarter, clearer trends have emerged. This release, we re-calibrate our FCAS market curve...

Regulation and policy

Calm after the storm although transition begins to lag | 2023 year in review

This year saw a return to relative calmness after the energy shocks of last year, while governments are playing an increasing role as the rate of new renewable generation lags. Spot pricing was subdued compared to last year, with no significant unexpected outages that caused sustained price spikes. Higher levels...


Offshore wind now appears in latest ISP

The ISP also forecasts that greater flexible gas generation is needed From Cornwall Insight Australia's Energy Market Alerts service Offshore wind officially appears in the draft 2024 ISP due to state-based offshore wind targets. Figure 1 below from our latest Energy Market Alert, shows the variance in forecast generation between...


New South Wales REZ outlook

From Cornwall Insight Australia's Energy Market Perspective Our quarterly Energy Market Perspective contains an analysis of indicative capacity at REZ zones throughout the NEM.  The following assessment for NSW is from our latest edition. Request Energy Market Perspective call back The strategic development of Renewable Energy Zones (REZs) in New...


Capacity Investment Scheme boosted from 6GW to 32GW

From Cornwall Insight Australia's Energy Market Alerts service Last Friday, the Commonwealth announced a major boost to the Capacity Investment Scheme, with the scheme now expected to deliver 32GW (combination of 9GW firming capacity and 23GW renewable generation) – up from 6GW. Cornwall Insight Australia has released an Energy Market...


What are Australia’s emissions reduction targets?

From Cornwall Insight Australia's Energy Market Alerts service Energy laws have now been amended to incorporate an emissions reduction objective alongside the other objectives. The list of targets that the market bodies will need to consider is listed in a separately published Targets Statement. The targets currently listed cover both...


Energy prices tumble in October

From Cornwall Insight Australia’s NEM Market Analysis report With over 700 GWh of rooftop PV added to the NEM since October last year, records were again set in NEM minimum demands along with a high instantaneous renewable penetration within the grid of 71.4%. Once again, the month’s main story was...


Emissions intensity drops for October 2023

From Cornwall Insight Australia’s NEM Market Analysis report This October saw a 12.6% reduction in total emissions (accounting for -1.18 Mt CO2-e reduction) as solar and wind generation has increased significantly. The reduction in emissions may continue with the arrival of Fly Creek and Rye Park wind farms expected soon...