Government moves to mandate SMETS2 installations, but at what cost?

There is little more than a month to go until 15 March, after which date first generation smart meters (SMETS1) installed for prepayment purposes or by suppliers with derogations will not count towards smart meter roll out targets.

However, there is now another deadline looming, with BEIS consulting on its intentions to activate the New and Replacement Obligation (NRO) on 31 March. This will effectively require suppliers to take all reasonable steps to install a SMETS2 meter when a replacement meter is required, or where a meter is installed for the first time. The “all reasonable steps” element also allows consumers to refuse to have a smart meter and permits the installation of non-SMETS2 meters in emergency circumstances, such as where health and safety is compromised. Exceptions to the NRO also exist where current transformer meters are already installed, or where a non-domestic, non-microbusiness customer has chosen to have an advanced meter.

The NRO is intended to ensure that up to date smart meters are installed wherever possible. The goal is also to ensure that customers receive the benefits of smart metering and to avoid increased costs to industry and negative impacts on consumers if a traditional meter then has to be replaced with a smart meter within a short period of time.

The NRO has long been in the energy supply licences but requires Secretary of State activation before coming into effect. In 2015 BEIS took the decision to activate the obligation in mid-2018, and last year revised the timing to not be before 2019. Despite this, the proposal to switch on the obligation at the end of March comes at short notice, with less than a month to respond and just over a month from the consultation close date before the obligation is activated. These timescales will present a challenge for suppliers to use up their existing SMETS1 and traditional meter stocks before the proposed activation date.

While the SMETS1 end date means that first generation meters will no longer count towards roll out targets, the NRO is a harder hitting deadline, after which not taking all reasonable steps to install a SMETS2 meter will put suppliers in breach of their licence.

However, the requirement is one that the industry will find it difficult to comply with as there are a number of barriers to installing a fully functional SMETS2 solution. In particular, there are still difficulties with getting hold of the meters, there are communications problems in the North of England and Scotland, and prepayment metering using SMETS2 is not yet ready for high volume installation. If suppliers are constrained to install SMETS2 meters that simply do not function as intended then there is an argument that installing a SMETS1 meter would result in less detriment to the customer, particularly as the meters should eventually be able to be enrolled in the DCC and offer similar levels of functionality as SMETS2 meters. It would be hard for Ofgem to justify enforcement action in such situations, especially given its move to a more principles-based approach to regulation in which the onus is on suppliers to understand and deliver positive outcomes to customers.

We anticipate that some suppliers will make the arguments for a more market-driven approach, allowing the rising costs of SMETS1 and traditional meters to drive the move towards the cheaper SMETS2 meters. When the objective of the programme is to equip all domestic and small business customers with smart meters, some participants will argue that it is odd for the government to maintain the upcoming SMETS1 end date and effectively prohibit further installations when we still don’t have a comprehensive SMETS2 solution available at scale. BEIS could have rescheduled the end date and NRO activation until the SMETS2 solution is fully viable. All SMETS1 devices that could not be enrolled in the DCC would have to be replaced before the final roll out deadline. This alternative approach would have allowed suppliers to make decisions over the most appropriate meters for their customers at the time, taking into account operational issues on a case by case basis.

The consultation on the NRO proposals closes next Tuesday, and it will be interesting to see how BEIS responds to what we expect to be considerable pushback from industry.

We can help you keep track of all these developments via our Smart Meter Regulation Service. To find out more please contact Rowan Hazell at or call 01603 542128.

Related thinking

E-mobility and low carbon

2022’s most exciting ‘Charts of the Week’

Some of our team have looked back throughout 2022 and picked their most exciting ‘Chart of the Week’.​Their choices include exploring green tariffs, wholesale gas prices, CfD allocation round 4 and the MHHS Implementation Levy.  It’s My Birthday – Two years of Dynamic Containment Picked by Tom Faulkner, Head of...

Low carbon generation

UKERC issues response to REMA consultation

On 3 November, UK Energy Research Centre (UKERC) published a response to BEIS’ Review of Electricity Market Arrangement (REMA) consultation. Our experts discuss what the response addresses and how some of the proposals would place new responsibilities on retail energy suppliers. Read the full blog on our What is REMA portal, which...

Business supply and services

Improvements for microbusinesses in the market begin to take effect

Before energy prices began to really soar, in March this year we saw the final package of reforms following the Microbusiness Strategic Review from Ofgem. The outcome of the review was to introduce changes to supplier licence conditions that would improve how microbusinesses are treated in the market. The new...

Regulation and policy

Energy Price Guarantee to end in April

I was not surprised by the announcement from the Chancellor today (17/10) regarding the shortened time period in which the domestic Energy Price Guarantee (EPG) will apply, for all the reasons discussed in our report -  Energy Price Guarantee - Counting the Cost - and my accompanying blog. Our report...

Regulation and policy

Government to consult on the introduction of Cost-Plus-Revenue Limit

The government issued its Energy Prices Bill on 12 October. The bill will put in law a number of the already-announced mechanisms that will be used to support households and businesses this winter including the Energy Price Guarantee and the Energy Bill Relief Scheme. Also announced alongside this is the...

Energy storage and flexibility

From zero to hero: Can CfDs split markets and reduce costs this winter?

Given media comment on the imposition of a revenue cap for low carbon generators instead of migration of existing projects onto a CfD, please find below a blog published by Cornwall Insight three weeks ago. Not only did this note the possibility of the revenue cap being a fall back...

Regulation and policy

One-hit wonder? Assessing the government’s business support scheme

Subsidising the unprecedented cost of energy for both households and businesses came in at the forefront of the Chancellor of the Exchequer, Kwasi Kwarteng’s “mini-budget” last Friday. Described as “one of the biggest interventions ever made”, Kwarteng confirmed a three-step plan. Firstly, as announced on 8 September, the introduction of...

Low carbon generation

MCS Charitable Foundation – Hydrogen Costs

MCS Charitable Foundation (“MCS”) in its charity goal of decarbonising homes, heat and energy has commissioned us to calculate the costs of blue and green hydrogen, based on current and projected gas prices. This report sets out our methodology for this forecast, and our findings in terms of delivered prices...