High and Volatile: Trends from our Q421 Green Power Forecast

At the end of January we released our latest Green Power Forecast, projecting renewables generators revenues over a five-year horizon whilst also providing Power Purchase Agreement (PPA) pricing and benchmarking updates, and a survey to gauge the latest renewables market trends.

Amid the current “energy crisis” arising from an underlying rise in wholesale prices, forecast renewable generators’ revenues have risen significantly. However, the ramifications of the current crisis are far-reaching, with PPAs being no exception.

In this blog we explore some of the latest trends in key revenue streams for renewables assets.

Wholesale prices up significantly, but cannibalisation impacts loom

Wholesale power contracts rose considerably over Q421 (October – December), where seasonal contracts out to winter 26 lifted ~25% on average. Gains in wholesale prices were most pronounced in nearer-term contracts: contracts for near-term delivery saw the largest increases, with the summer 22 contract up nearly 70% quarter-on-quarter, and the winter 22 contract trading in excess of 70% higher.

Power contracts have risen due to record high gas prices in the so-called energy crisis, in conjunction with strong performing underlying commodity markets (such as LNG and carbon prices), and a trend of low wind and renewable generation during the quarter.

Despite these highs, price cannibalisation—the depressive influence on the wholesale electricity price at times of high output from intermittent weather driven generation such as solar, onshore, and offshore wind—continues to affect the captured wholesale price of wind and solar technologies.

Captured prices in Q421 achieved by wind technologies averaged ~8% below baseload prices (assessed using the Market Index Price), while solar PV prices instead averaged 1.2% higher than baseload prices in the quarter, buoyed by its daytime generation profile. Nonetheless, the recent surge in wholesale prices saw solar PV and wind captured prices (i.e. absolute £/MWh values) in Q421 rise notably, once again breaking records in our analysis since January 2015. Figure 1 below shows the monthly captured price for wind and solar technologies between January 2020 and December 2021, with the impact of the surge in wholesale power prices hard to miss.

Roc prices are trading at elevated levels, whilst FiT generators enjoy option to switch

Generators accredited to the Renewables Obligation (RO) scheme have also benefitted from healthy forecasts of Roc values, at least for the near future.

Traded Roc values in the current compliance period (CP) CP20 (2021-22), have risen in light of low wind output persisting across most of the year. For CP21 (2022-23), the RO target being set at the second highest level has also benefitted RO-accredited generators, resulting in expectations of greater Roc demand from electricity suppliers, and therefore the potential for a high Roc recycle value to be realised.

Unlike other subsidy schemes, RO generators remain entirely exposed to volatile wholesale prices, and therefore the rise in wholesale power prices of late will be a welcome change from the extreme lows observed during the peak of the COVID-19 pandemic. However, the extent of any additional revenue from realised Roc values will ultimately depend on prevailing trends within any CP, such as renewable output and electricity demand levels.

Meanwhile, FiT generators have enjoyed their ability to switch between the administered export tariffs set by Ofgem, and a commercial PPA that includes prevailing wholesale prices and other sources of revenue such as embedded benefits. This is an annual choice, where the latest export rates have been set at £55.70/MWh (2021-22 money) or £39.50/MWh (2021-22 money), depending on accreditation date. As the front annual baseload power price remained markedly higher than both the lower and higher export rates during Q421, averaging £132.84/MWh, FiT projects were reported to be increasingly switching away from the administered export tariffs and onto commercial PPAs.

REGOs are trading at all-time highs

REGO prices have maintained a strong upwards trajectory in 2021 and into 2022, repeatedly breaking record highs across both fuelled and unfuelled technology types.

Increasing demand for REGOs, in part following low wind output across most of 2021-22 has supported prices for the certificates, particularly in the near-term; REGOs for the 2021-22 Fuel Mix Disclosure (FMD) period have reportedly traded in excess of £6/REGO in recent months. While it is generally expected that REGO prices for future FMD years will subside from the current highs, relatively high values have nonetheless been reported by market participants. This is starkly contrasted to traded REGO values prior to 2021-22, where values were rarely reported above £1/REGO, particularly during the initial stages of the COVID-19 pandemic when REGOs traded below £0.2/REGO at times.

While gains have been most pronounced in nearer-term FMD year REGOs, prices for later-dated REGOs have also risen, with prices further along the curve being buoyed by increased demand from corporates, who are increasingly using REGOs as part of their ESG reporting.

Our quarterly Green Certificates Survey explores certificate pricing trends in more depth, with the latest report issued only yesterday.

But PPA pricing has become more challenging

While forecast green generators revenues have risen, a welcome change compared to projections during the peak of the COVID-19 pandemic, the energy crisis has impacted actual achievable values for renewables sites. This impact is exemplified by the latest trends reported in the PPA market, as part of our conversations with market participants.

Against a backdrop of extreme levels of volatility in the wholesale market and in imbalance prices, alongside uncertain output levels and the impacts of price cannibalisation on intermittent asset types, offtake parties providing PPAs have had to adjust their offerings. This has made the job of pricing PPAs more difficult, ultimately resulting in reduced % value retention (against full market values) that generators are able to achieve in the market. Some market participants in our survey noted that offtakers found fixed-price PPA offerings particularly challenging, and are instead preferring to offer market-indexed PPAs. That being said, the reduction in % value retention levels in PPAs has more than been offset by the underlying rises seen in key revenue streams available to renewables, namely wholesale prices.

If you are interested in our Green Power Forecast report, forecasting a wide range of revenue streams available to renewables assets whilst also providing bench PPA pricing levels and a survey of trends in the wider renewables market, please contact b.bagge@cornwall-insight.com or t.ross@cornwall-insight.com.

Related thinking

Business supply and services

Ofgem reaches conclusion for the Microbusiness Strategic Review

The Microbusiness Strategic Review came to a close on 28 March 2022, with four finalised proposals from Ofgem that aim to protect microbusiness consumers and create a more robust framework through which the market can operate. Following the unprecedented rise in wholesale prices and recent geopolitical events, these changes are...

Low carbon generation

Are renewables the answer to Ireland’s energy crisis?

The current crisis in the energy markets may seem like it’s all doom and gloom, every week another electricity or gas supplier announces a price hike with the consumer powerless, at the whim of the global commodity prices. However, offshore wind presents a unique opportunity for Ireland, to both decarbonise...

Commercial and market outlook

Perspective | Is the design of the electricity market costing consumers money?

This article is from our Energy Spectrum publication which was published on 4 March 2022. It has become increasingly clear the existing market design is unfit for either a future net zero world or a period of fossil fuel price crisis, but what market design might be best for our...

Commercial and market outlook

Russian gas dependency and impacts on net zero

Tensions along the Russia-Ukraine border have been escalating since November last year when satellite imagery showed a fresh build-up of Russian troops on the Ukrainian border. Fast forward to the 24 February 2022, Ukraine and Russia are now at war following a Russian invasion. In response to these actions from...

Home supply and services

The risks of short-term interventions distorting long-term incentives in the energy market

Christmas 2021 was not a time of cheer for the energy industry and its customers. There is acute stress on energy suppliers and consumers from current bills - let alone where they may move to in the coming year. And it seems the political and regulatory debate has moved on...

Commercial and market outlook

2021’s most exciting ‘Charts of the week’

Some of our team have looked back throughout 2021 and picked their most exciting 'Chart of the week'. Read about their choices and click through to read the full 'Chart of the week'. To do so, you need a free Cornwall Insight account which is easy to create here. Green...

Commercial and market outlook

Price cap set for 46% rise for Summer 2022, Winter 2022-23 cap may exceed £2,000

Following further highs in wholesale prices and the costs associated with the raft of supplier failures seen in the last few months, Cornwall Insight is forecasting that the domestic default tariff price cap for Summer 2022 will increase to approximately £1,865 per annum for a typical dual fuel customer, with...

Energy storage and flexibility

Five highlights from our latest PPA market research

Recently, as part of both our Renewable PPA Market Share and Green Power Forecast reports, we have undertaken research into the renewables PPA market, hearing views from generators, offtakers and other renewables PPA market participants. Our recent Chart of the Week detailed the latest research from our Renewable PPA Market...