Innovation and regulation – changes on the horizon for auto-switching

In this week’s Flexible and Responsive Energy Retail Markets consultation[1], the government and Ofgem stated that “the ability of the current arrangements to provide consistent and appropriate protections is already tested by the growing role of price comparison, auto-switching and brokering services”. As an unlicensed sector, the regulator has set out different options for increasing the oversight of intermediaries, including auto-switching platforms. 

Over the last two years, there has been an increasing number of intermediaries entering the market that differ from the traditional price comparison websites (PCWs), with 10 companies now offering an automated switching service. At present these are only in operation in the domestic market. The largest service, Look After My Bills has continued to be at the forefront of media attention, while advertising from GoCompare about its WeFlip platform has shown a concerted effort to grow its customer base.

These services have already seen investment, firstly through the acquisition of Flipper by Wessex Water in June 2017, which it said it would “help to drive the next phase of Flipper’s development”, and then a £120,000 investment for Look After My Bills after appearing on Dragons’ Den in August 2018. This was followed in April 2019 by Verv’s acquisition of Labrador Energy.

While two of these 10 services (Flipper and Switchd) are paid for by the consumer via a membership fee, most auto-switching companies are commission-based, operating in a similar way to PCWs. Today, the total number of customers subscribed to automated switching services is now in excess of 160,000 users. Still a relatively small part of the switching market, these services have grown in popularity over the last year, up from 40,000 in 2018.

Investment activity, growing use of auto-switching services by consumers, and indications from government and Ofgem that the current energy retail market structure is ripe for change clearly signals that the market for consumers outsourcing their purchase decisions has plenty of opportunity to grow.

However, it was during last summer that the media first reported some suppliers refusing to switch customers through auto-switching services, citing customer service problems, a failure to pass on important information to customers and data protection fears. Following escalation to Ofgem, the regulator said suppliers are obliged to accept transfers from auto-switchers. More recently, suppliers have noted an added complexity arising from change in property ownership, where the previous owner or tenant has signed up to an auto-switching platform, but not notified the company of their change of address, resulting in an unexpected switch for the new owner/ tenant. The aforementioned consultation is the vehicle through which these issues should be addressed.

And this month This is Money stated that some suppliers are no longer offering commission. This is not unusual, however, as there are numerous suppliers that do not pay commission to PCWs. Ultimately, the choice of channel for suppliers reflects their overall strategies, including the types of consumer the supplier is looking to acquire, their expectations around retention and cost of acquisition. This dynamic would be radically different if auto-switching services become prevalent.

As the regulator looks to develop new licences or authorisation for these companies, it will need to weigh up ensuring appropriate consumer protection against consumer convenience and not unduly dampen innovation. The lessons learnt from the emergence of PCWs will help here (such as codes of practice ruling how tariffs are ranked), and it will be in the interests of the auto-switching services to be seen to be the honest broker.

Of all involved, it is likely the supplier who faces the biggest challenges from auto-switch services. After years of regulatory intervention to make suppliers better engage with consumers, the market may have hit on a means for the consumer to easily and fully outsource the processes of this to somebody else – and dare we say on a day like this, do something more enjoyable like grab an ice-cream!

Our Domestic Energy Sales Channels report explores the commercial models, challenges and opportunities associated with different sales channels in the domestic market. For more information, please get in touch with Kate Hill on k.hill@cornwall-insight.com or 01603 542136

[1] Flexible and Responsive Energy Retail Markets. Published on 22nd July by BEIS and Ofgem

Related thinking

Home supply and services

Rocketing energy prices and failing suppliers—what is happening?

Sky high gas prices and energy suppliers going out of business have been key headlines in the news over recent weeks, but what is actually happening?  Through the COVID-19 pandemic we saw much lower gas prices, which have been surging upwards since the spring and risen rapidly through the summer, a time...

Home supply and services

The default tariff cap and the law of unintended consequences

With all eyes on the immediate challenges facing the energy supply market and the impact of the default tariff cap as a contributing factor, it is important to note that the cap for the coming winter period should not be considered in isolation and that attention will swiftly turn to...

Business supply and services

Have we given up on competition in the retail market?

“Q: How does 2pm on Wednesday sound? A: Assuming we still have a functioning energy market that'd be great”.  It’s not really what you expect to see in an email at 5pm on a Friday when trying to arrange a call. But then these are certainly not normal times. In this Energy Perspective, we will...

Home supply and services

Consolidation in the energy market predicted to continue

It has been a turbulent time for the retail energy market, experiencing a period of consolidation with mergers and supplier exits. This supplier consolidation is expected to continue in the near term. If suppliers fail to shift their business models for the new world it is likely to continue, according...

Home supply and services

“Green” tariffs in the spotlight as BEIS commences review

With the announcement on 16 August of a call for evidence on Designing a Framework for Transparency of Carbon Content in Energy Products, consultant Josephine Lord looks at the issues being considered and what the future may hold for so-called “green” tariffs. The call for evidence is the first step...

Regulation and policy

How will consumers take to Market-wide Half Hourly Settlement?

Ofgem published its decision to implement the move to Market-wide Half Hourly Settlement (MHHS) on 20 April. This confirms plans to move to new settlement arrangements over a four and a half year time period, with the Elexon-led Design Working Group’s Target Operating Model to be used as the blueprint. Meters...

Regulation and policy

Ofgem raises modifications ahead of RCC and new switching arrangements

The latest edition of our Faster Switching Service Report due to be issued this week includes the latest developments in Ofgem’s Switching Programme and the associated Retail Energy Code (REC). Launched in November 2019, the Retail Code Consolidation (RCC) Significant Code Review (SCR) set out Ofgem’s intention to amalgamate the...

Regulation and policy

Calm before the storm? 2021 energy supplier compliance developments

The latest update to our Energy Supplier Compliance Portal went live on 4 May and includes changes to the compliance landscape during February to April 2021. While the previous quarter’s update reflected new principles resulting from Ofgem’s Supplier Licensing Review (SLR) and protections for prepayment meter customers facing self-disconnection, Q121...