Crying over spilled solar – how much can a battery help?

A standalone battery earns its revenue not only from the arbitrage opportunity between day and night prices but also from participation in FCAS markets. This remains true when the battery is paired with a solar farm but can be complicated by constraints or trade-offs between FCAS participation and solar export. When optimising for maximum trading profit, this can play out in ways that seem, at first glance, counterintuitive or even counterproductive.

In this Chart of the week, we look at the behaviour that such a hybrid system can exhibit when wholesale market prices are low and solar energy generation is high.

To do this, we have used Cornwall Insight Australia’s Storage Investment Model (SIM) to simulate a 100MW 2hr battery and a 100MW solar farm in a hybrid AC-coupled system[1] with a 100MW transmission connection. The SIM maximises the net operating profit from the hybrid system for each trading day, optimising the dispatch of the solar farm and the battery in each market (wholesale + 8 FCAS) for each half-hour interval.

An average time-of-day capacity enablement profile for 2031 (after the LRET scheme ends) for the hybrid system in each of these markets is shown in Figure 1. While the solar farm is actively generating, the capacity offered into the Raise and Lower Contingency FCAS markets is generally lowered accordingly.

However, the top and bottom of the figure in the middle of the day highlight two types of constraints that can suppress the amount of solar energy that can be exported to the grid:

  • Direct solar export to the grid can be constrained by the maximum capacity of the transmission connection:
    • If this is lower than the sum of the solar peak capacity and the battery power capacity (which may happen if TUoS charges are high or if line capacity is constrained), then there will be a trade-off between the solar generation export and the battery’s participation in FCAS markets.
    • If wholesale prices are low, then it may be optimal to spill the solar energy and reserve transmission capacity to participate in Raise FCAS markets instead.
  • Charging the battery behind-the-meter from solar can be constrained by the battery inverter’s maximum power capacity:
    • If wholesale prices are zero or negative, it may be optimal to instead spill the solar energy and reserve inverter capacity to participate in Lower FCAS markets.
    • This will generally be the case if a suitably large arbitrage opportunity is not present (or forecast) in the evening peak period.

The net effect of each of these types of constraints can be observed in Figure 2, where the grey area represents the solar energy spilled. When looking at how large this amount might be, note that this behaviour occurs because there is more profit to be made by instead allowing FCAS participation.

Of course, there would be many ways in which this behaviour may be altered or avoided, depending on the priorities of the project proponent, including but not limited to:

  • DC-coupling the battery and solar farm to remove or reduce the bottleneck of the AC inverter capacity on BtM charging of the battery from solar;
  • Increasing the maximum transmission connection capacity, up to the sum of the solar generation and battery inverter capacities, if network conditions and economics allow; or
  • Running a more aggressive arbitrage strategy to force higher solar energy utilisation, at the expense of FCAS participation.

Our in-house Storage Investment Model can provide in-depth revenue forecasting and optimisation services to help investors and developers determine the right approach for their projects. For more information, please contact

[1] Key modelling assumptions:

  • Located in the Darling Downs Renewable Energy Zone (REZ) in Southern Queensland.
  • Battery registered to provide up to 50MW of Regulation FCAS, and 52MW of Contingency FCAS (average recent Contingency FCAS registration of other market batteries in the NEM)
  • 1-year (2031) model run, with battery capacity degradation and solar output degradation ignored

To keep reading, please log in to your account or sign up for free

Alternatively, please sign up to receive free market insight online and direct to your inbox

Related thinking

Commercial and market outlook

How does thermal storage stack up compared to batteries?

Along with the retirement of coal/gas power plants in the NEM, long-duration energy storage systems (LDESS), often exceeding 8 hours of storage, are becoming more crucial in transitioning to a more sustainable and renewable energy future. LDESS technologies, such as battery storage systems (BESS), thermal energy storage systems (TESS), compressed...

Commercial and market outlook

VNI West selected path; an incentive for delaying coal retirements?

On 29 May 2023, AEMO published a conclusions report on the VNI West Project. According to the report, option 5A (a variant of  AEMO’s preferred option in a previous consultation paper) is preferred for VNI West. In option 5A, the transmission line crosses the Murray River north of Kerang (Wamba...

Commercial and market outlook

Spot the spread: Are current battery revenues enough to encourage further investment?

In AEMO’s ‘Step Change’ scenario, it was estimated that storage capacity in the NEM would need to increase by a factor of 30 between 2022 and 2050 to support a grid transformation that limits temperature rises below 2 degrees. This represents about 13GW of new storage capacity by 2030 and...

Power and gas networks

Trouble Ahead? – What’s Next For TNUoS Charges?

Some industry participants will be well versed in the Transmission Network Use of System (TNUoS) charging regime, while others may not have had to engage with it before. Regardless of previous involvement, these charges are becoming increasingly important to understand for reasons we will discuss shortly.  In this week’s ‘Chart...

Commercial and market outlook

Feast or famine? FCAS costs in South Australia

Frequency Control Ancillary Service (FCAS) prices are highly volatile, at times resulting in short periods of extremely high FCAS cost. Three such events in recent history are the South Australian (SA) islanding events in November 2019, February 2020, and November 2022. During these events, FCAS costs in SA totalled $16...

Low carbon generation

NSW’s transition to a new era: What will replace Eraring?

After 52 years of operation, the NSW Liddell power station officially shut down last 28 April. With Liddell’s closure, NSW’s transition to a green energy future is in full swing. First announced in 2015, NSW had seven years to ensure there is enough replacement capacity once Liddell is retired. Since...

Commercial and market outlook

It’s the Liddell things that matter

Australia’s oldest coal-fired power plant Liddell retired completely in the last week of April 2023 after 52 years. This giant of AGL, which had a total registered capacity of 2,000 MW, operationally acted as a 1600MW station and 1200MW after the closure of its third unit. Australia’s transition to clean...

Energy storage and flexibility

A look at AEMO pre-dispatch forecasts over the last year

The Energy Security Board (ESB), under the direction of the National Cabinet, is currently working on a number of changes that will impact how generators connect to and operate within the National Electricity Market (NEM). The Congestion Relief Market (CRM) model is one such change to how the NEM currently...