VNI West selected path; an incentive for delaying coal retirements?

On 29 May 2023, AEMO published a conclusions report on the VNI West Project. According to the report, option 5A (a variant of  AEMO’s preferred option in a previous consultation paper) is preferred for VNI West. In option 5A, the transmission line crosses the Murray River north of Kerang (Wamba Wamba Country) instead of near Echuca, which was initially proposed in option 5. Option 5A has now been accepted by the Victorian government.

Although option 5A has several advantages, such as harnessing more renewables and lesser environmental effects, it results in some notable changes in coal generation. Namely, according to the conclusions paper[1], coal generation will increase during 2030-2033 by ~1 TWh a year.

In this Chart of the Week, we discuss how this increase in coal generation (due to VNI West development) might justify a delayed retirement for some coal generators.

Figure 1 below shows the annual coal generation outlook in NSW (based on 2022 Integrated System Plan (ISP) assumptions), available coal capacity in the state, and the time window that represents the required additional coal generation as a result of VNI West development (~1 TWh a year between 2030-2033).

As seen in Figure 1, Eraring will be retired well before 2030, and Bayswater will be retired in 2033. As a result of Eraring’s retirement, there will likely be some response by coal in NSW to meet the state’s energy needs. Therefore, with the additional required coal generation between 2030-33 (yellow window in the figure), it could be an incentive for Vales Point, and probably Bayswater, to consider delaying their retirement as this additional generation might also result in a change of capacity factor for the remaining coal in NSW.

The estimated additional coal generation during 2030-33 due to VNI West development accounts for ~6.5% of the annual expected total coal generation during the time. While this additional coal generation will be dispatched between all coal generators, it still represents an incentive for Vales Point not to leave the game for another couple of years if there is a significant enough increase in NSW prices as a result of this increased export requirement into VIC and the percentage of this additional TWh of generation that it can capture.

Currently, NSW is currently lagging against its energy transition targets. Although the allocation of long-term energy service agreements (LTESAs) in the state can speed up the process, NSW is still vulnerable to coal retirements, at least price-wise. If the transition continues to lag against the expected target, the volume of generation that may be required to be satisfied by coal could be larger. Therefore, it will be interesting to see how this forecasted increase in coal generation could incentivise Vales Point to delay its retirement.

Another point to consider is that the increase in the required coal generation as a result of VNI West planning might not reflect the most efficient solution for emissions reduction. Energy Ministers have agreed to fast-track the introduction of an emissions reduction objective into the three national energy objectives. Although the final bill on the integration of emission reduction objective is not effective yet, it is in question if the new law can accommodate the expected increase in coal generation between 2030-33 through other planning functions.

In this Chart of the week, we benefited from our Energy market Alert services which provides a comprehensive and up-to-date analysis of the major regulatory, policy and market developments. Please contact us at for more information. 

[1] Figure 11 in the conclusions paper shows the changes in generation output with Option 5A VNI West.

To keep reading, please log in to your account or sign up for free

Alternatively, please sign up to receive free market insight online and direct to your inbox

Related thinking

Commercial and market outlook

The Very Fast FCAS market is about to commence – a look at a possible time-of-day profile for R1

On 9 October 2023, 1pm (market time), the dispatch of the new Very Fast (VF) FCAS market in the NEM will commence and will add two new markets for contingency FCAS, Raise 1 (R1) and Lower 1 (L1). AEMO has released a final industry go-live plan to keep track of...

Low carbon generation

“Ooh, a storm is threatening, My very [interconnection] today”: Can states utilise interconnection to share wind resources?

Penetration of renewables continues to dominate the energy news, as we saw renewables as a proportion of total demand reach new heights this week to a new record of ~70% penetration. In light of this continuing march toward a renewable-dominated grid (building on some analysis we did in Chart of...

Energy storage and flexibility

How long is the ‘Golden time of day’ for batteries?

A key part of the business case for grid-scale standalone batteries is the arbitrage opportunity between low daytime wholesale prices (when renewable energy generation from solar is plentiful) and high evening prices (when the sun goes down and household demand ramps up quickly). The share of battery revenue coming from...

Low carbon generation

MLF changes in NSW in the past decade

MLF, short for Marginal Loss Factor, represents the portion of electricity losses that occur along the transmission network between a connection point and the Regional Reference Node (RRN). Within the NEM, the MLF serves as a metric to quantify these losses along the network, playing a pivotal role in determining...

Energy storage and flexibility

Spread your wings and arbitrage away as Q2 sees ‘the spread’ increase

The focus of batteries is constantly adjusting to reflect ‘where the money is at’. Various quarters have trends, and others have events that swing momentum. With FCAS enablement in Q2 this year dropping to some of the lowest values since 2016, shifting the solar curve, or rather arbitrage, became the...

Commercial and market outlook

Zap, Crackle, Pop! SA’s shocking electric dance party on the 11th

Across the mainland states in the NEM, South Australia (SA) relies heavily on variable renewable energy (VRE) resources. SA is an excellent subject to test the premise “What if the wind doesn’t blow, and the sun doesn’t shine”? Negative spot prices persist in South Australia due to an abundant supply...

Commercial and market outlook

Polarisation of wholesale spot prices leads to opportunity for arbitrage services

Over the last five financial years, South Australia has seen a significant increase in price volatility, with substantial portions of time both negative and above $250/MWh, leading to increasing opportunities for storage systems to provide arbitrage services. A number of events initiated the reduction in wholesale energy prices between $50/MWh...

Energy storage and flexibility

Proposed changes to PFR and the impact on battery operations

On 3 August, at the request of the Australian Energy Market Operator (AEMO), the Australian Energy Market Commission (AEMC) initiated a rule change request proposing to “clarify the mandatory primary frequency response (PFR) obligations of scheduled bidirectional plant (i.e. batteries with a capacity of 5MW and greater)”. One of the...