Questions from the British-Ireland Parliamentary Assembly

Ruth Young, Senior Consultant at Cornwall Insight Ireland and Robert Buckley, Head of Relationship Development, recently participated in a session at the British-Ireland Parliamentary Assembly to address recent energy trends.

They prepared a sample of the briefing notes with answers to:

What are the main challenges governments in the BIPA jurisdictions face in meeting demand for energy?

  • We are back to the Trilemma of affordable, secure and low carbon energy sources.
  • The most material risk across the board is loss of investment – the macroeconomy is driving up costs of investments, compounded by risk of near-term interventions and political uncertainty all against the backdrop of radical market reforms.
  • Energy margin risks associated with ageing assets.
    • In Great Britain there is a risk of nuclear plants reaching the end of their lifespan early or facing running issues.
    • In Ireland we are seeing some fossil fuel plant obliged to close due to EU legislation whilst others are reaching the end of their life where it is uneconomic or impossible to keep running.
    • In the Republic of Ireland we have also recently seen that the capacity market is failing to deliver and the government has had to intervene through the delivery of generation via emergency routes.
  • There is a need for diversification of technologies to meet demand whilst achieving decarbonisation targets. The current investment environment is not conducive to all technologies. There is also a need to provide system flexibility to match the widespread roll out of renewables.
  • There is a lack of public consent and understanding – both need to make both the risks and benefits of the net zero transition clear.
  • There is a lack of long-term infrastructure investment

In the UK and Ireland we have seen that funding very high consumer bills at short notice is very expensive. Consider the cost of implementing domestic energy efficiency measures versus the cost of the UK’s Energy Price Guarantee.

Do the governments in the BIPA jurisdictions have effective strategies for meeting demand for energy in the future?

  • The outline is in place, but it is lacking policy detail to provide certainty on some big assumptions that preferred technologies work and turn up on time (Historically large dependable units, now moving to a world of intermittency that the system is not designed for).
  • The increase of intermittent generation increases the need for flexibility to ensure security of supply. There is little in the way of strategy relating to flexibility in both the short and long term.
    • Not all low carbon flexibility options lend themselves to the BIPA jurisdictions but a review of possible solutions would provide some focus. For example, the UK is looking at CCS due to heavy industry and natural storage, but this solution doesn’t lend itself to Ireland’s system as well.
    • The lack of policy on flexibility is causing hesitance in investment as there is no indication from gov on how to support a renewables led system causing. In Ireland this is resulting in the continued build out of gas.
  • Cannot just consider generation, there is a case for increased integration of demand side participation and storage.

Energy Spectrum Ireland

Our Energy Spectrum Ireland service is a paid-for subscription which consists of a weekly news bulletin and a monthly publication which dives deeper into key market, regulatory, policy and transactional developments in the Irish and Northern Irish energy sectors.

This month,

  • our Policy section covered the government’s Climate Action Plan 2023
  • our Regulation section explored Forward Work Programmes issued by the SEM Committee and the UR. We also look at CRU’s 2022 customer survey report.
  • our Industry section summarises the Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland’s annual analysis on energy trends, targets, policies, and actions.
  • our Markets page provides data on the volatile movements seen through December

Sign up for a free trial, and a member of the team will be in touch

Alternatively, we are always happy to speak to you directly, if you would like to speak to our team, please contact Magdalena on m.jennings@cornwall-insight.com

Related thinking

Low carbon generation

Save it for later: the role of LDES in Ireland’s future power system

In its transition to net zero, Ireland’s power system will undergo fundamental changes as it shifts from a reliance on thermal generation from imported fossil fuels to generation from indigenous, intermittent, renewables. Among these changes is the growing need for flexibility to help maintain system stability. This includes the provision...

Low carbon generation

Blowin’ in the Wind: Is offshore wind the answer to Ireland’s net zero future?

As Ireland works towards achieving net zero by 2050, there is a pressing need to develop additional renewable energy capacity. Offshore wind is likely to be a particularly important sector and, thanks to Ireland’s large offshore exclusive economic zone, presents a valuable opportunity for the Irish economy. Cognisant of this...

Low carbon generation

De-risking renewable development: CI RESS Model inspires policy changes in RESS 3 T&Cs  

Last year, we partnered together with Wind Energy Ireland (WEI) to produce a report titled “Improving Revenue Certainty and Risk Allocation for New Renewable Generators”, which explored potential auction policy changes for the RESS auction that would help de-risk renewable investment for developers and generators. At the heart of this...

Regulation and policy

Government to implement EU measures to address windfall gains

On Tuesday 22 November, the government announced that it will implement Council Regulation (EU) 2022/1854 to address windfall gains in the energy sector. This will include a cap on all market revenues of non-gas electricity generators, with excess revenues to be collected and used to support electricity consumers. The cap...

Low carbon generation

Diversifying the Irish Energy Mix, could hydrogen be the answer?

The recent news that Nord stream has resumed flows into Europe will ease some of the fears of supply shortages heading into the winter for us all and have associated knock-on effects pricewise. Although back flowing, the EU commission on Wednesday urged countries to cut gas use by 15% over...

Low carbon generation

RESS 2 by numbers

Last Friday, RESS 2 auction results were published, with nearly 2GW of new renewables projects successful in getting awarded a contract. We have put together an infographic that explains the auction outcome and what these projects will bring to our electricity system. We have also released a report with Wind...

Commercial and market outlook

Editor’s Pick Ireland | SEAI: Transport takes the largest share of energy in Ireland

Energy-related CO2 emissions fell by 1.2% in 2018, according to the latest publication of Energy in Ireland, an annual report by the SEAI which presents the key trends in energy production and consumption. Published on 12 December 2019, the report shows how Ireland's energy system is evolving in response to...