Scottish government calls for auction system review after CfD AR3 results

On 20 September, BEIS announced the results of the Contracts for Difference (CfD) Allocation Round 3 (AR3). The auction results cleared at record low prices with 2023-24 delivery year prices at £39.65/MWh and 2024-25 prices at £41.61/MWh. The results drew criticism from the Scottish government despite projects in remote islands winning contracts for the first time (see our blog on 23 September).

Two advanced conversion technology projects, six offshore wind projects and four remote island wind projects with a combined capacity of 5.77GW were awarded contracts.

Six of the 12 projects, which are located off the coast of Scotland, are shown in the table below.

Despite the relative success of Scottish projects, there were several notable projects that failed to win contracts. Pertinent to Scotland, the 90-turbine Moray West Offshore Wind Farm (sister project to the Moray East wind project) was unsuccessful in its CfD auction proposal, as was Red Rock Power’s Inch Cape Wind Farm off the Angus coast. Several other remote island wind projects are also failed in their bids, such as the Viking Wind Farm joint venture between the Shetland community and SSE.

It is these failures, along with exclusion of other technologies that the Scottish government would like to deploy at scale, that provoked a call from Scotland’s Energy Minister Paul Wheelhouse for the UK government to urgently review the limitations of the auction system, and how it is impacting Scotland’s own infrastructure development targets.

He acknowledged that, while some of Scotland’s island projects have done well, “serious questions remain as to whether these will be enough to secure our key objective of transmission links to these islands in the near future.” Developing Scotland’s network infrastructure was listed as a priority in Scotland’s Electricity and Gas Networks: Vision to 2030, which was published in March.

Wheelhouse also believes that “floating wind, wave and tidal developers must be given the same opportunity to deploy devices at scale and drive down costs.”

We expect calls from the Scottish government for further energy market reform to intensify as decarbonisation and energy system targets between Scotland and the rest of the UK diverge. As we go to press, the Scottish government has announced landmark legislation that will commit Scotland to becoming a net zero society by 2045 – five years before the rest of the UK.

To keep up to date on policy and industry developments in the Scottish energy sector, follow the daily news feed on Scottish Energy News or sign up to our weekly newsletter. For more information, please contact Neil Mearns at

UK government           Scottish government

Related thinking

E-mobility and low carbon

Is Europe’s EV uptake stalling? EV Country Attractiveness Index findings

In the first quarter of 2024, battery electric vehicle (BEV) sales and public charge-point installations have continued to grow across Europe. The new financial year has also seen many countries implement new subsidies to spur further growth. Amid this, conversations continue around the influence of cheap Chinese imports across European...

Low carbon generation

Blowin’ in the Wind: Is offshore wind the answer to Ireland’s net zero future?

As Ireland works towards achieving net zero by 2050, there is a pressing need to develop additional renewable energy capacity. Offshore wind is likely to be a particularly important sector and, thanks to Ireland’s large offshore exclusive economic zone, presents a valuable opportunity for the Irish economy. Cognisant of this...

Regulation and policy

Government Announces Record Budget for Contracts for Difference Allocation Round 6

The government has released the budget and reference prices, along with the auction parameters, for the upcoming Contract for Difference (CfD) Allocation Round 6 (AR6). As recently reported, there were considerable questions outstanding about the parameters which will be used in the auction and significant pressure was placed on AR6...

Low carbon generation

Learning curves and the many moving parts of the CfD Auctions

Learning curves are an important part of the toolbox of energy system modelling, representing the benefits of learning by doing and the economies of scale. The learning rate describes how as production doubles capacity cost reduces, so a learning rate of 15% would imply that as production doubles, costs would...

Commercial and market outlook

What to look out for in 2024

Cornwall Insight experts provide their predictions for the year ahead in this handy infographic. We have collated some predictions from across our knowledge base to provide a quick snapshot of what to look out for in the GB energy market in 2024. The key highlights include the global discussion on...

Regulation and policy

Calm after the storm although transition begins to lag | 2023 year in review

This year saw a return to relative calmness after the energy shocks of last year, while governments are playing an increasing role as the rate of new renewable generation lags. Spot pricing was subdued compared to last year, with no significant unexpected outages that caused sustained price spikes. Higher levels...

Net zero corporates and ESG

Race to net zero: Rebuilding investor confidence in the UK

In our recent insight paper “Race to net zero: Rebuilding investor confidence in the UK”, published on 30 November, we discuss how increased macroeconomic pressures and rising international competition for capital have impacted the UK’s ability to secure investment in renewables and maintain momentum towards net zero. We also investigate...

E-mobility and low carbon

Paving the way: EV Country Attractiveness Index findings

Following the previous iteration of the EVCA Index, published in September 2023, the EV market has continued to grow across Europe. From October 2022 to October 2023, the EU, Norway, and the UK have seen a combined 29% year-on-year increase in battery electric vehicle (BEV) sales. Cornwall Insight have partnered...