The Balancing Mechanism and BSUoS under lockdown

The COVID-19 pandemic and subsequent lockdown restrictions have severely impacted the GB energy market with demand and prices at record lows. As market conditions have drastically changed, National Grid Electricity System Operator (NG ESO) has been much in the spotlight, with the current low demand scenario providing new operational challenges. In recent months activity in the Balancing Mechanism (BM), as well as other balancing services, has changed in response to these new challenges. This has had knock-on impacts for Balancing Services Use of System (BSUoS) charges.

Following on from our recent blog on rising BSUoS costs and the raising of CUSC modification CMP345 seeking to defer these, we look more closely at why costs are rising and how the BM is operating under lockdown.

In the BM, parties submit bids and offers to the ESO providing details on their availability to adjust generation or demand and the price at which they are willing to do so if required. During April and May 2020, the volume of accepted actions in the BM more than doubled compared to the same time last year.

Overall, across the two months of April and May 7.1TWh of actions were accepted compared to 3.3TWh in April and May 2019. Accepted bid volumes (to reduce generation or increase demand) in May rose from 0.80TWh in 2019 to 1.86TWh in 2020. However, a similar rise in accepted offer volumes (to increase generation or reduce demand) shows that actions have not purely been to reduce generation at times of low demand, with 1.92TWh accepted in May 2020 against 0.69TWh in May 2019.

Much of these actions have not been taken to purely match supply and demand, but also to manage an imperfect physical network and maintain stable operating conditions. For example, the ESO is often required to turn down output from Scottish generators on windy days due to insufficient transmission capacity to transport the electricity south. On similar days, with high levels of asynchronous generation and low demand levels, the ESO also needs to ramp up output from synchronous generators (typically CCGT plant but also potentially coal-fired assets) to maintain adequate levels of system inertia. This limits the potential for large and rapid deviations in frequency, with the frequency level needing to be maintained at very close to 50hz in order to keep the system stable.

As a result of these issues, actions taken on the BM can be classified as either an energy or system action. An energy action is made purely to match supply and demand while a system action is taken due to wider system requirements such as network constraints, inertia or voltage management. The increase in bid and offer volumes during this low demand period indicates that a higher proportion of actions are being taken to resolve other system issues too.

In May 2020, 2.43TWh of the total accepted volume of 3.78TWh were classified as system actions, representing 64.4% of total accepted BM volumes in the month. In contrast, May 2019 saw 0.55TWh of system actions against a total of 1.5TWh, equating to 39.7% of overall accepted volumes. This highlights the challenge of balancing a system with low demand and high penetration of renewables. It is not just about managing supply and demand at a national level (energy actions), but also maintaining system inertia levels and managing local network issues.

This increase in accepted volume on the BM is reflected in BSUoS charges. The average half-hourly BSUoS charge in April and May 2019 was £2.82/MWh and £2.56/MWh, respectively. This has risen to £4.93/MWh and £5.75/MWh in April 2020 and May 2020 (based on interim Information (II) settlement run data).

COVID-19’s impact on demand was expected to increase the £/MWh rate of demand-based industry charges, all things being equal. However, added to this rise has been the overall increase in BM volumes and other balancing services actions which have combined to push BSUoS even higher. This is reflected in the total daily BSUoS charge, which has increased from £2.9mn in May 2019 to £5.2mn in May 2020.

With exceptional market conditions and the ESO noting up to £500mn in additional BSUoS costs over the summer period, on 19 May SSE Generation raised CMP345 Defer the Additional COVID-19 BSUoS Costs. This seeks to defer the additional BSUoS costs arising from COVID-19 that are incurred in 2020/21 (between 1 May and 31 August 2020) to the 2021/22 Charging Year. The Code Administrator Consultation is open between 9-12 June, with implementation planned for 23 June 2020, to be backdated to be effective from 1 May 2020.

With increased BSUoS costs coming at a time of difficulty for the market, the deferment of additional BSUoS costs would be a welcome relief to suppliers and transmission connected generators alike.

Cornwall Insight provides a range of services covering GB flexibility markets and system operation. Our Balancing Mechanism Reporting Service provides monthly updates on BM activity, new entrants and imbalance pricing and cost trends. For more information please contact Lee Drummee at 

Related thinking

Energy storage and flexibility

Waiting to connect: the problems and solutions for network connection queues (Part 2)

Network connection queues continue to be a notable topic of interest as many generators face significant delays to project development – an issue that is directly conflicting with net zero ambitions and recent focuses on strengthening domestic energy supplies. In Part 1 of our two-part series on connection queues we...

Energy storage and flexibility

Waiting to connect: the problems and solutions for network connection queues

The number of grid applications has risen significantly in recent years, resulting in increased pressure on the electricity networks to facilitate new connections. In its Energy Security Strategy, the UK government set out ambitions for 95% of electricity to be sourced from low carbon generation by 2030, and for the...

Home supply and services

The role of smart meters in energy security

Smart meters have the potential to play a critical role in energy security, providing near real-time information through a visual in-home display, empowering consumers to change how much energy they use and when they use it. If consumers reduce or shift their energy consumption away from peak periods, they may...

Energy storage and flexibility

Balancing Reserve: ESO proposes new regulating reserve service

In recent months National Grid ESO has been developing a new reserve service to improve the management of the system and enable the grid to accommodate zero carbon operation of the electricity system by 2025. On 28 September the ESO first announced at their Autumn 2022 Markets Forum, a proposal...

Power and gas networks

Gas DSR reforms ahead of winter 2022-23

National Grid has recently carried out a review of the Gas Demand Side Response (DSR) voluntary curtailment mechanism through July and August. The Gas DSR allows shippers to offer a consumption curtailment service to National Grid Gas (NGG) during periods of acute gas supply constraint called a Gas Deficit Emergency...

Energy storage and flexibility

Dialing up the unknowns on network charging

In a world of open governance code modifications, change is a constant. You only have to look at the number of code modifications ongoing at any one time – National Grid lists 36 modifications in development relating to transmission network charging alone – for evidence of that. But in recent...

Commercial and market outlook

Capacity, reform, and unlawful strategies: 5 things that happened yesterday

Capacity, reform, and unlawful strategies: yesterday was a busy day for energy geekery. The developments encapsulate the shorter and longer term challenges and uncertainties present in the energy market presently: Read the full article here

Energy storage and flexibility

Network charging – what’s been going on and why should I care?

Across Great Britain there are ~810,000km of wires and underground cables that make up our electricity network. Split between the higher voltage, transmission system and the lower voltage distribution system, these lines and cables are responsible for transporting electrons up and down the country to provide consumers with the necessary...