Whiter than white supply?

SSE and M&S Energy announced on 5 July that their nine-year domestic supply partnership had ended, with the contract formally expiring on 28 September 2018. Here we comment on the evolution of such white label partnerships in the domestic supply market, their successes, and the recent moves we’ve seen in this sector.

The idea of white labelling energy supply is not a new one. SSE and M&S Energy operated a successful partnership for nine years before it ended, while British Gas’ white label agreement with Sainsbury’s Energy has operated since 2011. However, this method of market entry is becoming more attractive as an alternative to fully licensed supply, with 16 white label suppliers now active in the domestic market, 12 of which have entered over the last two years.

And it’s clear to see why. White labelling offers a less complex and less costly method of entering the GB supply market compared to a fully licensed route. It allows companies to offer energy supply to their existing customers/residents, without the burden of additional regulation or installation of new systems, commonly using those of their fully licensed partner. It also provides a revenue stream through payment of commissions to the recruiting entity.

And there is a growing local dimension. Of the 16 white label suppliers now offering tariffs, 10 are local councils, bringing regional change in their communities by offering lower priced local tariffs and supporting the reduction of fuel poverty for residents in their local area typically by reducing standing charges or offering best terms to smaller properties. Eight of these companies have opted to partner with Robin Hood Energy, Nottingham City Council’s supply company.

However, while there has been increasing interest in white labelling, the number of customers served by this supply group remains relatively low. Less than 4% of the domestic energy market is served by the 16 white label suppliers, reflecting their (sometimes) regional focus (particularly of the local council brands), or niche customer targeting – see Ebico, a not for profit supplier targeting low consumption customers. But by far the majority of this is accounted for by the two large supermarket chains.

It is also a market that has undergone change in recent months. In April this year, student bill splitting company Glide opted to move its customers from its supply partner Ecotricity, to Spark. On a larger scale, Ebico ended its partnership with SSE in early 2017, stating that the two companies’ strategies “no longer align”. In the most recent market move – SSE and M&S – both companies have been clear to state customer communications will be transparent, and they will outline the options available when the contract comes to an end in September.

While it’s early days following the M&S Energy announcement, we await with interest to see which way the company moves. As one of the more established white label companies, either way could be an important juncture for white label models.

Contact A.Moss@Cornwall-Insight.com for more information about this development and wider supply market trends.

Related thinking

Low carbon generation

New transmission charge forecast will help generators managing cost uncertainty and volatility

Transmission network use of system (TNUoS) charges represent a significant proportion of operating costs for many renewables generators, often exceeding 50% of annual running costs. For some, as recently highlighted by SSE in a recent report and to Members of the Scottish Parliament, they could present a barrier to investment in generation...

Business supply and services

A look back at 2020 part 3

As we take our first steps into 2021, we continue to look back at the biggest developments in the UK energy markets in 2020, setting us up for the significant year ahead. The mergers and exits from the supply market that were seen in 2019 continued into 2020 and led...

Announcement

Celebration: Cornwall Insight wins second FT award

Tom Palmer, our managing consultant, discusses our recent success of achieving a bronze award for consulting from the Financial Times for the second year running. Last week we discovered that for the second year running we have been rated in the top 20 Management Consultants for Energy, Utilities and Environment...

Home supply and services

The competition is on in the domestic energy market

It is difficult to deny that the Big Six have faced significant competitive pressure in the domestic market over the course of the year. Despite the 11 domestic market exits recorded since January 2019, new entry, new propositions and revitalised sales channels have resulted in some of the highest switching...

Low carbon generation

SSE to close unit at Fiddler’s Ferry

SSE’s announcement to close a unit at its Fiddler’s Ferry coal-fired power station has come as little surprise as challenging market conditions continue for the technology, and the government remains committed to phasing out coal-fired generation by 2025. The Fiddler’s Ferry plant in Warrington, Cheshire, has a capacity of almost...

Home supply and services

Match abandoned: SSE and npower exemplify tough playing conditions in supply

SSE has announced that the merger of its GB retail supply business with npower has been called off. It was clear that the deal was in trouble back in early November when SSE told the stock market that the terms of the merger were being re-negotiated. This was always a...

Announcement

Cornwall Insight Response to MMO

Ofgem has just put out its decision on the Market Making Obligation. The headline is that the regulator will not suspend this year the initiative that helps smaller parties access electricity wholesale products, but is likely to do so once the SSE/ Npower merger and the acquisition of Scottish Power’s...

Commercial and market outlook

Energy Perspective | Energy Spectrum Issue 628

In this week’s Energy Perspective, we dissect a week that has seen three suppliers from very different backgrounds effectively stop trading. With five forced exits from the retail market since November 2016 there is little doubt that suppliers are facing more challenging conditions. However, we believe these events have also...