The net zero paradox – challenges of designing markets to bring forward low marginal cost resources

The scale and speed of the net zero targets require a refocus of the traditional goals of electricity market design to ensure efficient dispatch, adequate capacity and optimal investment. Electricity markets need to support the investment and dispatch to meet low carbon objectives, but the fundamental drivers of the electricity market are changing with the addition of zero marginal cost variable renewables and this makes returns lower and more unpredictable, and investment harder.

The paper then considers a number of possible market designs which could improve investment signals for the low carbon future and attempts to assess which one could optimally meet our low carbon objectives.

Tom Edwards, Cornwall Insight , Senior Modeller commented

“The energy transition is shaking up energy markets around the world, the falling costs of renewables make them easier to deploy and displace traditional generation technologies. The current market designs are by no means perfect, but they are not well designed to cope with a technology mix dominated by large quantities of zero marginal cost and meet our low carbon objectives we would expect to see in order to reach net zero. We consider several market designs which could be better at deploying large quantities of zero marginal cost generators to complete our journey to a decarbonised electricity system.”

To keep reading, please log in to your account

Related thinking

Regulation and policy

Reform options for TNUoS and constraint management

This report explores the potential to enable the decarbonisation of the GB energy system and meeting net zero ambitions through evolutionary reforms to the transmission charging and constraint management arrangements. Cornwall Insight is an independent energy consultant with extensive experience in market and policy analysis. This report was produced by...

Energy storage and flexibility

Ready and waiting: Opportunities for energy storage

As the UK transitions towards net zero, the increasing share of the energy generation mix coming from renewables is resulting in greater intermittency of generation, leading to a growing system need for flexible dispatch solutions. Produced in conjunction with DLA Piper, this report provides a background to energy storage and...

Low carbon generation

Is Germany going green? Charting Germany’s energy transition

Using exclusive insights from our new North West Europe Benchmark Power Curve, our insight paper assesses the impact of the energy crisis on Germany’s net zero ambitions and attainment. Current and future policy decisions are unpacked and evaluated to determine their impact on the net zero investment landscape, with the...

Business supply and services

Business net zero: Making progress in a challenging economy

In light of the financial pressures faced by enterprises from rising inflation and interest rates, tight supply chains and labour markets, alongside high energy bills, this paper investigates to what extent decarbonisation is still a priority for corporates and how progress towards net zero has been impacted by recent developments....

Energy storage and flexibility

Co-location, co-location, co-location

As the UK transitions to net zero, the energy generation mix will become increasingly dominated by intermittent renewable generators, thus promoting a need for greater flexibility within the energy system. Setting up a new site, especially for storage assets, is currently a long and often costly process. Co-location is where...

Energy storage and flexibility

Unlocking REMA

Recent challenges have emphasised the recurring importance of the energy trilemma, namely the need to decarbonise the energy system while ensuring energy security and affordability. The government announced its Review of Electricity Market Arrangements (REMA) in April 2022 to address these issues. In July, the government published a consultation paper...

Low carbon generation

MCS Charitable Foundation – Hydrogen Costs

MCS Charitable Foundation (“MCS”) in its charity goal of decarbonising homes, heat and energy has commissioned us to calculate the costs of blue and green hydrogen, based on current and projected gas prices. This report sets out our methodology for this forecast, and our findings in terms of delivered prices...

Business supply and services

Weathering the storm: Mitigating the impact of energy price hikes for businesses

The challenging gas supply situation and record-high electricity prices are putting considerable pressures on the GB economy as we enter winter 2022-23. Unfortunately, as the winter approaches, wholesale energy prices are set to rise even further, constraining the growth of businesses that were starting to recover from the scars of...