Energy System Reform: Ofgem shares plans for Britain’s energy system

Against the backdrop of record high and volatile energy prices, Ofgem set out on 8 July its view on key aspects of the GB energy system where it considers significant reform is required to deliver a resilient, low cost, low carbon energy sector.

Recent developments in the energy market, such as the unprecedented rise of wholesale gas prices since Autumn 2021 have, in Ofgem’s view, reinforced the case for moving away from our reliance on fossil fuels and to focus instead on accelerating the decarbonisation of the energy system. The regulator has therefore identified three challenges to overcome to reduce energy system costs by more than £10bn per year by 2050. This includes strategic planning and coordination, optimising the energy system, and stabilising and reforming the retail market.

Ofgem highlights the need for a mixed approach to system coordination due to the complexity of necessary upcoming infrastructure changes. The required developments will be characterised by long lead times, uncertainty, new and emerging technologies, as well as dependencies between different energy assets. Therefore, to keep costs down, strategic planning and coordination will be required across current (electricity and gas) and emerging (e.g. heat networks) energy assets. The regulator also notes the challenge of determining the optimal balance between network capacity and greater use of flexibility. It is proposed that the Future System Operator (FSO) will lead the national planning of the strategic electricity and gas networks necessary for a net zero energy system. It will also advise both the Government and Ofgem for the planning of decarbonisation of generation, heat, and transport, as well as facilitate competition in delivering new cost-effective infrastructure. Ofgem further proposes the establishment of a body (or bodies) to deliver planning and coordination at a sub-national/regional level to support the development of local energy networks, flexibility options, and the reliable, transparent operation of local energy systems. Proposed bodies include distribution network operators, gas distribution networks, and local government.

With the anticipated increase in solar and wind generation capacity in the coming decades, it is expected that surplus clean energy will drive down the cost of wholesale electricity. However, in instances of insufficient renewable energy, there will be greater demand for higher priced energy sources, such as natural gas or low carbon alternatives for baseload demand, which will in turn set the price for the electricity market. This could lead to higher-than-necessary costs for consumers and returns for investors, which has been dubbed the “marginal pricing challenge”. In response to this, Ofgem proposes reforms to the wholesale market. An example reform would see the market split into two, with one market for intermittent power paid at a fixed unit price, and the other for firm power paid at market prices as per current arrangements. Alternatively, a faster and simpler route to delivering much of the benefits of a split market would be expanding the use of Contracts for Difference which pay low carbon generators a fixed price for energy and will pay back to consumers when the wholesale electricity price is high, effectively protecting them from market price volatility.

Additionally, onshore and offshore wind generation is likely to be concentrated in locations far from large centres of electricity demand. In the interest of reduced system costs, Ofgem notes the potential to unlock locational flexibility through the development of granular market signals, estimating that this could save billions of pounds annually. Proposed approaches include a move to locational marginal pricing which would see a split of the electricity wholesale market into zones or nodes to allow prices to differ by location. This would encourage investment in well-placed flexible energy assets and send location specific signals to those assets in real-time, minimising system balancing costs.

The recent unprecedented wholesale energy price increases have resulted in more consumers struggling to pay energy bills and has placed a greater strain on the retail market. Improvements to the energy market will look to provide more opportunities for consumers, with Ofgem proposing actions to stabilise the market by introducing a tougher regulatory approach. This would ensure suppliers are financially resilient in their business models and make the price cap more resilient to market volatility. This includes Ofgem’s decision to make changes to the price cap wholesale methodology, seeing the move from six-monthly cap updates to quarterly cap updates; and a reduced notice period of 30 working days, which is split between five working days for Ofgem to calculate and publish the new cap level followed by 25 working days for suppliers to notify customers and implement the new price level to coincide with the start of each quarter. Decisions such as this aim to lower the risk of supplier exits and ensure minimal disruption and cost to consumers if they do.

Alongside this, Ofgem has also stated that the proposals have been developed with the intention that customers are able to “benefit from more affordable, homegrown, and renewable energy”, and as such has committed to creating framework that prioritises consumer interest.

Ofgem will be continuing to evaluate reform options with the aim of concluding in early 2023, having already begun investigating these proposals further. These include a detailed technical assessment of the potential benefits, costs, and implementation requirements associated with a transition to a zonal or nodal market design with the report expected in Autumn 2022. Ofgem is also undertaking a programme of work looking at the longer-term purpose and structure of transmission network use of system charges, and review of distribution use of system charges. Furthermore, an update on its retail strategy is expected to be published later this year.

If you are interested in deepening your understanding on the aspects covered in this blog, we welcome you to attend our Net Zero Transition: Future Power Markets training course from 27 to 29 September which forms part of our ‘Net Zero Transition’ training series which introduces a range of scenarios for the evolution of the GB electricity market to 2050, some of the technologies that may be required at scale to meet net zero, and considers future market design, such as Locational Marginal Pricing and the Review of Electricity Market Arrangements (REMA).

Related thinking

Regulation and policy

One-hit wonder? Assessing the government’s business support scheme

Subsidising the unprecedented cost of energy for both households and businesses came in at the forefront of the Chancellor of the Exchequer, Kwasi Kwarteng’s “mini-budget” last Friday. Described as “one of the biggest interventions ever made”, Kwarteng confirmed a three-step plan. Firstly, as announced on 8 September, the introduction of...

Low carbon generation

MCS Charitable Foundation – Hydrogen Costs

MCS Charitable Foundation (“MCS”) in its charity goal of decarbonising homes, heat and energy has commissioned us to calculate the costs of blue and green hydrogen, based on current and projected gas prices. This report sets out our methodology for this forecast, and our findings in terms of delivered prices...

Energy storage and flexibility

Electricity network reform: where are we now?

In its Energy Security Strategy (ESS), the UK government set out ambitions for 95% of electricity to be sourced from low carbon generation by 2030 and for the UK to have a fully decarbonised electricity system by 2035. In order to accommodate this ambition, the electricity network will need to...

Energy Market Design

How does REMA impact energy generation, flexibility and consumers?

The Review of Electricity Market Arrangements (REMA) is the largest review programme of GB electricity market arrangements for a generation. It comes at a time when European energy markets are suffering extreme turmoil. Depending on the outcome there could be significant implications for generators, flexibility providers, and, indirectly, consumers. REMA...

Home supply and services

Highlights from our Energy Supplier Compliance webinar

As part of our Energy supplier compliance portal service, we run a webinar every 6 months which looks at key updates.    Our latest webinar looked back at the decisions made under Ofgem’s financial resilience plan. This included strengthening milestone assessments and introducing additional reporting requirements. It also decided on the short-term interventions...

Energy Market Design

REMA: electricity market design choices

Electricity markets will serve as the foundation for the future GB energy system.  This article examines some of the market design decisions that will be considered by the Review of Electricity Market Arrangements (REMA). Market design goals At its most simple, a well-functioning market will attract enough potential “buyers” and...

Low carbon generation

Head to Head: CfD vs RESS

2022 has been busy for renewable developers in Great Britain and Ireland, with both the fourth allocation round of the Contracts for Difference (CfD) scheme and the second round of the Renewable Electricity Support Scheme (RESS) concluding this summer. We compared the latest results of the CfD and RESS schemes...

Energy Market Design

Can we fix the wholesale energy market this winter to lower prices and should we want to? 

The Review of Electricity Market Arrangements (REMA) is intended to discuss and decide on appropriate market arrangements for 2035 in a Net Zero, low marginal cost, renewables-dominated market. It is unlikely it has the scope or capability to intervene in the market arrangements ahead of this winter. Therefore, some new interventions...